Katie's Pies and More is the best place to get desserts (and more)!!! I've never had something I haven't loved! I can't even pick a favorite... her pies are A-MAZ-ING! Cinnamon rolls OMG! Her cakes are gorgeous and delicious! Her cupcakes can't be beat. Scones...let's talk about the perfection! Cookies.... 100%
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Wedding Cake
Lemon meringue pie was fantastic! Mom loved it!! Thank you for your yummy goodness 😊
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I'm conflicted which is their best pie - the pecan, pumpkin, apple, cherry or key lime pie. My fourteen Thanksgiving guests tasted all five pies and debated into the night concluding that they all were the best pies ever eaten. Hoping that they expand to adding crusty breads to their menu.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$100+
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Love Nicoma Park now has sweet shops.
I had a mini Tres Leches cake. It’s topped with mixed fresh fruit. Soooo good!
It’s located behind Simple Simon Pizza. Just follow the candy canes.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
This pie was YUM! 🤤I’ve been hinting to my husband that a local bakery had an awesome looking Peanut Butter Chocolate pie. He surprised me today for my birthday with it! My oldest son said it was 10 stars and all 3 of my kids asked if they could have it for their next birthdays too! Ordering and pick up was super easy.
I had my mother in laws birthday cake made here. It’s was so beautiful and delicious 🤤 I was giving several options on flavor, size and shape, I was able to choose my picked up day and time. Another plus was the fast response. I’m so happy with the service and results that I have already placed my next order for a graduation cake. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ from this customer
It’s taken me a while to actually post a review for Katie’s Pies, but the longer I think about it the more I want people to know.
I’m usually all about local industry, but I was severely disappointed with our wedding cake I paid Katie hundreds of dollars to make.
I am including a picture to show that it was leaning and melting before the wedding even started. Not just the reception, the entire ceremony. She asked me to see the cake before the ceremony and before I paid, and I did, and was honestly so disappointed by it when I saw it. But by the time it was on the table and I was looking at it, it was going to be too late to get another cake.
My colors were rose gold, gold, and cream. These colors do not match what I requested. The pink was almost lavender. The gold was brassy. The cream was white.
I’m also including a picture of our groom’s cake. I bought the topper that was a wife dragging a groom from fishing. But she literally included Nemo and Dory fish like it was a cartoon cake, which I didn’t request. It felt like a joke. And the makeshift “dock” she says she made, was also melting and falling apart before the reception even started.
This was the happiest day of my life and I did not let her cakes ruin it. But it was a damper on the day and something I wish I could back and hire someone else for.
I see her recommended a lot, and I’m sure her pies and cupcakes are great. But I would not hire Katie or recommend her to anyone that wanted a wedding cake or groom’s cake.
